Foods

Onion Prices Are High. The Buffer Stock Is Not the Whole Answer.

Onions are dear again, and the government’s own numbers explain why the problem is harder than a single price line. Retail rates were around ₹60 a kilo in early November, up from ₹37.87 across 579 centres in late August. Wholesale mandi medians in mid-November sat between ₹42 and ₹48 a kilo. The national production estimate says supply is comfortable. The biggest producing state says its kharif crop may be down by nearly 40%. Both statements are in the official and market record.

The gap between those two claims is what consumers are paying for. India’s all-India onion production for 2025-26 is estimated at 307.37 lakh tonnes, broadly flat against the previous year’s 307.67 lakh tonnes. That number supports the government’s position that there is no national shortage. It does not tell you when onions reach the market, what condition they are in, or who can afford them in November.

What the Prices Actually Say

Different price series measure different things. The all-India retail average of ₹37.87 on 26 August came from the Department of Consumer Affairs’ daily monitoring. By 1 November, retail prices in Indian markets were reported at about ₹60. On 16 and 17 November, wholesale medians across more than 450 mandis were ₹42 and ₹48 a kilo respectively. A 52-week high of ₹55 was recorded on 8 November in one wholesale index.

None of these numbers is wrong. They describe points in a chain: farm gate, wholesale mandi, city retail. The spread widens when arrivals are thin and traders are handling stored onions that have already incurred cooling and transport costs. Consumers see only the last number, which is why the official talk of adequate supply can sound remote.

October’s inflation data put the political weight behind the price. Onion prices rose 116% year on year, while potato prices fell 14%. Food inflation stood at 8.94% and headline inflation at 6.09%. Rural inflation at 6.63% ran well ahead of urban inflation at 5.41%. A vegetable that appears in almost every meal is doing a lot of work in that gap.

The Maharashtra Gap

Maharashtra is the swing state in the onion story. Its kharif crop, harvested from September onward, was estimated in late October to be down 30% to 40% because of uneven rain and poor moisture. Fresh arrivals from Karnataka, Andhra Pradesh and Rajasthan have begun, but they are not yet enough to replace the stored stock that normally carries the market through the festival season.

The result is a two-speed market. Export-grade bulbs from Nashik are quoting around 58 US cents a kilo, about 9% above October and more than five times the March level. Domestic buyers compete with exporters for the same cured onions, and Malaysia takes more than half its onion supply from India. A shortfall in Maharashtra therefore shows up in Kuala Lumpur as well as in Delhi.

The national number says adequate. The state number says short.

Why the Buffer Is Sold at ₹35

The government has procured 1.21 lakh tonnes of onions for its buffer and is selling them at ₹35 a kilo through NCCF, NAFED, Safal and Kendriya Bhandar outlets, as well as mobile vans. The first dedicated onion freight service, nicknamed Kanda Express, carried 800 tonnes to Delhi. Sales began in Delhi NCR in late August and were extended to cities with high prices, including Lucknow, Chandigarh and Ludhiana.

The ₹35 price is a subsidy instrument, not a market signal. Its purpose is to give consumers an alternative when open-market rates climb. It works where the distribution reaches: in Delhi in late August, retail onions were ₹62 a kilo while buffer stock was available at ₹35. It does not work where there are no outlets, and it does not increase the total supply enough to bring down the open-market rate on its own.

The buffer was built from direct farmer purchases, and the storage agency for 2026-27 is the Central Warehousing Corporation for the first time. Recovery rates have improved to 72% from 49% four years ago, a small but genuine administrative gain. More recovery means more onions actually reach the retail van.

Exports Are Not the Villain This Time

India exported about 3.82 lakh tonnes of onions in April-June 2026 to Malaysia, Sri Lanka, the UAE and Nepal. The Consumer Affairs Secretary said in August that there was no plan to ban exports. That position is reasonable while domestic production is flat and export demand is strong. A ban would protect consumers for a few weeks and then leave farmers with no buyer for a crop they have already planted.

This is a different situation from the classic onion spike, where export restrictions are the first reflex. Here the government is relying on buffer releases and calibration. It has said the scale and destinations of releases will change with market conditions. That is a more flexible tool, but it requires the administrative capacity to move onions quickly from Nashik to a deficit city.

Storage Is the Long Answer

India’s cold storage capacity is estimated at 40.22 million tonnes, with about 75% devoted to potatoes. Onions need ventilated, dry storage rather than cold rooms, and the country has far less of it near the farm gate. Losses between harvest and retail are the hidden tax in every price spike. Building onion-specific storage in Nashik, Lasalgaon and the Karnataka belt would do more than another round of mobile vans.

For now, the market is waiting on arrivals. The food ministry has said fresh kharif supplies are expected to gain momentum and prices should moderate. That forecast depends on weather and on the pace of arrivals at Lasalgaon. If the kharif crop is indeed 30% to 40% smaller, November’s prices may persist into December, and the buffer stock will be doing more than a cameo.

Also read: Food inflation at 8.94 per cent and what it means for the RBI.

Illustration generated with AI (Gemini 3.1 Flash Image) for The Crescent World.

Ganesh Kumar R

Ganesh Kumar R writes and edits The Crescent World, with a focus on India's economy, technology and its place in a multipolar world.

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button