Foods

The Tea Auction Sold 98% of Its Catalogue. That Is the Story.

Tea prices at the Coonoor auctions have risen on strong demand from exporters and blenders, with domestic buyers adding support. Global Tea Auctioneers reported that 98 per cent of both leaf and dust varieties on offer were sold, a clearance rate that tells you the market is short rather than merely firm. The leaf sale offered 15,87,452 kg and the dust sale 3,67,836 kg.

The gains were not uniform. In leaf CTC, the medium and plainer sorts were dearer by ₹4 to ₹5 a kilogram, and sometimes more, while fannings were up ₹3 to ₹4. In CTC dust, the medium and plainer sorts were up ₹3 to ₹4. Orthodox dust moved the other way, easing ₹4 to ₹5 with some withdrawals. A single auction can contain both a shortage and a glut, depending on which grade you are holding.

Why the leaf is short

Traders attribute the rise to a shortage of tea in South India from January to September this year, caused by weather. Too little rain in the growing months, followed by the onset of winter, reduces the volume of fresh shoots. The bush does not produce on demand. It produces on a cycle that depends on temperature, moisture and the interval between plucks.

Some traders also point to mechanised harvesting. Machines are faster and cheaper than hand plucking, but they take more leaf and leave the bush slower to regenerate. The effect is a lower yield over time, which shows up first in the auction volumes and then in the price. The industry has been arguing about this trade-off for years, and a short crop makes the argument sharper.

Who is buying

The demand is coming from exporters and blenders, with domestic buyers providing a floor. Export demand for Indian tea has been firm, and a weak rupee makes dollar-denominated sales more attractive to exporters. Blenders buy to keep their blends consistent, which means they cannot simply wait for a better price if a grade is scarce. They pay up or reformulate.

The split between CTC and orthodox explains the divergence in prices. CTC, the crush-tear-curl grade, is the base for most tea bags and mass-market blends. Orthodox tea is the leaf tea that sells at a premium and finds buyers in West Asia, Russia and parts of Europe. When CTC is short, blenders bid aggressively. When orthodox dust is plentiful, the premium collapses. This week, the mass market was tighter than the specialty market.

An auction is a census of the crop. When 98 per cent sells and the price rises, the shortage is already in the leaf.

The Crescent World

The price at the cup

A ₹4 or ₹5 move at the auction does not translate into ₹4 or ₹5 at the shop. A kilogram of tea makes hundreds of cups, and the retail price is dominated by packaging, branding, distribution and tax. But the auction price is the farmer’s price, and for a small grower in the Nilgiris or Anamallais, a few rupees a kilogram is the difference between a viable season and a loss.

For the consumer, the more relevant number is the one in the inflation data. Wholesale prices rose 12.3 per cent in October, driven largely by energy, and food inflation has been running above the Reserve Bank’s comfort zone for months. Tea is a small weight in the basket, but it is a visible one. A household that buys a packet every fortnight notices when the same packet costs more.

The minimum price argument

Producers have renewed their demand for a minimum sustainable price for tea, a floor below which auctions cannot fall. The argument is that the cost of production has risen faster than the auction average, and that small growers are being squeezed by buyers who control the timing of purchases. Buyers oppose a floor because it would remove the price discovery that makes an auction an auction.

Both sides have a point. A floor protects the weakest growers, but it also invites tea to move to other origins and encourages buyers to substitute. India already competes with Kenya, Sri Lanka and Vietnam on price and quality. A domestic floor that is set too high would not raise the farmer’s income; it would reduce the volume he sells. A floor set carefully, with a fund to buy the difference, might work. Nobody has published that design yet.

The winter test

The next few weeks will decide whether this is a spike or a season. Winter reduces yields in the southern estates, and the north Indian crop is largely between flushes. If arrivals stay low and export orders hold, prices will stay firm into the new year. If rain returns and the bushes flush, the premium will fade as quickly as it appeared.

There is also a currency channel. Food inflation has already broken the RBI’s ceiling once this year, and a weaker rupee makes Indian tea cheaper for foreign buyers, which supports export demand and domestic prices at the same time. That is good for the trade and awkward for the inflation target.

What to watch

Three indicators. The December auction averages at Coonoor and Kochi: whether the gains hold across grades or remain confined to CTC. The export order book: whether West Asian and Russian buyers keep buying at these levels. And the minimum price proposal: whether the commerce ministry moves from listening to drafting.

A tea auction is one of the last places in Indian agriculture where the price is discovered in public, lot by lot, in front of buyers and sellers. That makes it a useful thermometer. This week it read short, and the reading was backed by 98 per cent of the catalogue being sold.

Illustration generated with AI (Z-Image Turbo, rendered locally) for The Crescent World.

Ganesh Kumar R

Ganesh Kumar R writes and edits The Crescent World, with a focus on India's economy, technology and its place in a multipolar world.

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button