The Selectors No Longer Decide on Rohit and Kohli.

A BCCI source has said that the decision on Virat Kohli and Rohit Sharma is no longer in the hands of the selectors or the team management. The source, quoted by Dainik Jagran and reported on 20 November, said India want both batters at the 2027 World Cup if they remain fit and willing. No one at the board has said this on the record, and the source is unnamed. Even so, the message is unusually clear: the selection panel has been told not to make the call.
The quote that will travel is the blunt one. “We will need Rohit and Virat in South Africa. We won’t be able to win there without them. These two are legends. They will decide how long they want to keep playing cricket.” That is not a selection policy. It is an acknowledgement that the two players occupy a place in Indian cricket that a committee cannot simply vote away.
What the Source Actually Said
The report says the board had already conveyed its thinking to the team management and had received a response. “The matter is no longer in the hands of the team management or the selectors,” the source said. This follows months of speculation about whether the panel wanted to move on from Rohit, whose ODI form has slumped, and how it planned to handle Kohli, who has announced that the 2027 World Cup will be his last.
The timing matters. The report landed days after a poor tour of New Zealand. Rohit scored 0, 23, 0 and 7 in four innings: 30 runs at an average of 7.50. Kohli made 86 runs in the same four matches, 74 of them in one innings at Eden Park. India still won the series 3-1, and they won it with the ball. A team can win a series with its bowlers and still have a serious question at the top of the order.
Why the Numbers Worry
Rohit’s sequence against New Zealand is the immediate problem. Four innings, three single-digit scores, and no sign of the ball striking cleanly. He answered similar criticism in July with 138 off 110 balls against England at Lord’s, which is the best argument in his favour: the capacity is still there, even if the consistency has gone. Kohli’s case is different. His 86 runs in four innings is modest by his standards, but one of those innings was a substantial contribution in a winning cause.
Both men have retired from Test cricket and T20 internationals. ODIs are the only international format left to them. That makes every series an audition and every failure louder than it would have been in a three-format career. It also means the board has a limited sample to work with. There are only so many ODIs before the World Cup, and each one carries selection weight.
The message came from above the selection room.
Who Decides Now
Ajit Agarkar’s term as chairman of selectors ended on 4 October. Pragyan Ojha stepped in as interim chairman and was confirmed in the job on 19 October. If the Dainik Jagran report is accurate, Ojha’s panel inherits a narrowed mandate. It can pick the other eleven, but the two senior batters are effectively reserved places subject to form and fitness.
That arrangement is not without precedent in Indian cricket. Boards have intervened before to protect senior players, usually quietly and usually near a major tournament. What is new is the explicitness: a source saying the decision has moved above the selectors. It leaves Ojha with less authority than his title suggests and gives the players a kind of security that younger hopefuls do not have.
The report does not say what happens if their form does not improve. That is the gap in the logic. “Form and fitness” are quoted as conditions, but no one has defined the threshold. A run of low scores in the Asia Cup would test whether the board’s confidence is conditional or absolute.
The Road to 2027
The World Cup runs from 2 October to 21 November 2027 across South Africa, Zimbabwe and Namibia. India open against Australia at Newlands in Cape Town on 7 October and play Pakistan in Johannesburg three days later. Those two matches will define the tournament narrative before the group stage is old.
Before that, India have a manageable but meaningful runway: three home ODIs against Sri Lanka from 13 to 19 December, three against Zimbabwe from 3 to 9 January, the Asia Cup in June and July, and a reported six-match series in South Africa. Kohli’s record in South Africa is a specific reason for optimism. He made 558 runs in six ODIs there in 2018, including 160 not out at Newlands. Rohit struggled in the first four games of that series before a 115 at Port Elizabeth.
India have not played an ODI in South Africa with both of them since. That statistic is the quiet basis of the board’s view. Whatever the recent numbers say, the team has not tested its two most experienced batters together in the conditions where the tournament will be played.
What It Means for the Squad
If Rohit and Kohli are guaranteed places, the competition for the remaining batting slots becomes tighter. Shubman Gill, Shreyas Iyer and KL Rahul are established. The middle order has to carry the scoring rate that the older pair may no longer provide. A squad built around two 38-to-40-year-old batters needs pace in the positions around them, or it risks becoming too slow for a South African outfield.
The board’s message is also a message to the public: the era of these two players will not end in a selection meeting. For fans, that is reassuring. For Rohit and Kohli, it leaves the choice where the source says it belongs — with them.
Also read: Dhoni stopped playing in the IPL. Chennai kept him.
Illustration generated with AI (Gemini 3.1 Flash Image) for The Crescent World.



