Modi Asked Who Is Hiring. The Answer Is Still Thin.

Prime Minister Narendra Modi walked into FICCI’s centenary convention on 19 November with a question for India’s biggest business leaders: “Have you increased the salaries of your employees? Have you increased the number of your employees?” The question was reported by The Hindu and the Indian Express, and it was not rhetorical.
Modi pointed to a corporate tax rate cut from 30% to 22% and income-tax relief for individuals earning up to ₹12 lakh a year. If the state had given so much, he asked, where were the raises and the new hires? By the next morning, Congress had an answer of its own: this was a confession.
What Modi Said
The speech covered more than pay. The Hindu reports that Modi told industry that the Make in India message had not changed since Gandhi spoke of swadeshi in 1930. “You have completed 100 years, yet things remain exactly where they were,” he said. He criticised companies for treating “export quality” as a label for the best products while selling lower quality at home, and asked whether FICCI had made plans to use the free-trade agreements India has signed.
The most quoted passage was simpler. Corporate tax had fallen. Personal tax had fallen. Had salaries gone up? Had headcount gone up? “No!” he said, answering his own question. The Indian Express reported the same line under a headline about the corporate tax cut from 30% to 22%.
Why Congress Called It a Confession
Congress was quick to claim vindication. The Hindu quotes Jairam Ramesh saying that for the first time in 12 years a “nervous and rattled” prime minister had pulled up the captains of industry. He said Congress had been saying for years that wages had not risen, tax cuts had not produced an investment boom, and jobs were not expanding fast enough.
Rahul Gandhi went further. The Times of India reports him accusing the government of creating monopolies and asking how many jobs had been created by groups that had received ports, airports, coal, roads, power, mines and forests. He blamed demonetisation and the GST design for damaging small traders and MSMEs, and said monopolies raise prices and eliminate competition rather than create work.
Ramesh also claimed that imports from China would touch $150 billion this year, up from $112 billion, and that this was hurting MSMEs. That is a political claim from Congress, not a freshly published official number. It still points at a real issue: when cheaper imported components and finished goods flood domestic markets, small manufacturers lose orders before they lose margins.
The Number Missing From the Speech
What the speech did not provide was a measured answer to its own question. There was no new payroll series, no wage-growth number, no breakdown of formal versus informal hiring, and no estimate of how much of the corporate tax saving became capital expenditure. Without those numbers, the exchange becomes a contest of anecdotes.
That is a shame, because India already has enough evidence to have a better argument. The repo-rate debate is about whether credit becomes investment. The onion-price debate is about whether supply reaches consumers. The jobs debate should be about whether tax relief and capex incentives become regular monthly income for workers. All three are questions of transmission, not intent.
The question is not whether industry was scolded. It is whether the next budget measures the response.
What Would Change the Answer
First, the government would need to publish a simple scorecard for large tax and incentive measures: investment announced, investment completed, jobs added and wages paid. It is not an unreasonable demand. If public money is given on the promise of private action, the action should be counted.
Second, MSME policy has to move from loan guarantees to orders. Small firms hire when they have repeat demand, not when they have a subsidy letter. Public procurement, local sourcing by large firms and credible quality certification would do more for payrolls than another round of credit rearrangement.
Third, India’s FTAs need a domestic utilisation desk. Modi’s complaint that industry has not planned for trade agreements is fair. But many small exporters do not have the compliance staff to read rules of origin, product standards and tariff schedules. A trade agreement that only large firms can use will not create mass employment.
What It Means
Both things can be true at once. The government can be right that large companies have not shared gains with workers. Congress can be right that policy uncertainty and weak demand have held back private investment. The national interest lies in settling the argument with data.
For now, the most useful line from FICCI is not the partisan applause. It is the question itself. A growth story that cannot say who was hired and what they were paid is unfinished. The next test is whether the answer appears in the numbers, not in the next speech.
Also read: The repo rate is 5.50%. The argument is about 6.25% and Onion prices are high. The buffer stock is not the whole answer.
Sources: The Hindu, The Indian Express, The Times of India.



