Europe Has a Chair at the Ukraine Table. Russia Still Has to Take Its Own.

For two years Europe watched the Ukraine negotiations from the corridor. On Friday it was handed a chair. At an informal summit in Dublin, European Council President António Costa announced that the continent’s negotiating team would consist of the EU institutions plus five countries — France, Germany, Italy, Poland and the United Kingdom — a grouping Brussels calls the E5 of the Coalition of the Willing. The Commission, the Council and NATO will all be represented.
The decision is smaller than it sounds and larger than it looks. Europe did not win the right to set terms. It won the right to be in the room while terms are set, and it won that right from a Russian government that has spent the war refusing to sit with European officials.
The team, not the envoy
The team is not a diplomatic corps. It is a set of national security advisers working at what officials call the technical level, drawn from the five capitals and the EU institutions. That sets the altitude: heads of government are not negotiating; their advisers are. It keeps leaders free for the moment a deal needs signing.
The composition also settles a dispute that had become public. Italy’s Giorgia Meloni had complained about the “disarray” of European voices and demanded a single envoy. Poland had warned against Western capitals deciding matters for the eastern flank. Germany’s Friedrich Merz defended the existing E3 format of Britain, France and Germany, then conceded the obvious: “we always include Italy and Poland.”
The compromise was to stop choosing. Instead of appointing one person, the leaders enlarged the group. Costa framed it as arithmetic rather than diplomacy: “We need to integrate all of us. And for this it’s essential to have a team and to speak with only one voice.”
Europe did not win the right to set terms. It won the right to be in the room.
The Crescent World
The casualty
The decision leaves Kaja Kallas, the EU’s foreign policy chief, without the role she had spent the morning arguing for. Kallas said representing the bloc on foreign and security policy was part of her mandate under a 2024 leaders’ agreement, and that if capitals wanted to change it they could. She also acknowledged the obvious: “Russians do not want me.”
Costa’s response was procedural and cold. The treaties, he said, are clear: the Council president represents the Union on foreign policy at the level of heads of state and government. Commission President Ursula von der Leyen declined to back her own vice-president.
Why Europe had to be there
The substantive case was never sentimental. Europe holds the frozen Russian assets. Europe has paid the largest share of Ukraine’s budgetary and military support. Europe will pay most of the reconstruction bill. And Europe is the party that would have to live with whatever security architecture emerges on its own continent.
There is also a number concentrating minds: a financing shortfall for Ukraine of roughly 70 billion euros looming in 2027. A settlement that freezes the front line without answering who funds the Ukrainian state afterwards is not one Europe can survive politically.
Costa set out the scope carefully. Only Ukraine can decide matters of its territory and sovereignty. The EU should have a central role in Ukraine’s European future and reconstruction. Security guarantees belong to the Coalition of the Willing, in close coordination with NATO. Read together, those three sentences are a red line: no deal about Ukraine without Ukraine, and no guarantee that bypasses the alliance.
The Moscow problem
The agreement followed a trip that reframed the week. US envoys Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner flew to Moscow on Thursday and met President Vladimir Putin. Afterwards both indicated Moscow was willing to hold face-to-face talks with Europeans. The Kremlin spent Friday diluting the claim, saying it first wanted to understand Europe’s “real intentions and their willingness to contribute.”
That is the pattern of this process. Washington announces progress, Moscow says it is studying the matter, and the gap becomes the next round’s agenda. The talks have already moved through Miami, Oslo, Brussels and Abu Dhabi. Italian officials were present in Abu Dhabi this week; Polish officials are expected at the next round. European delegations were nearby but not inside the main sessions — precisely the arrangement Dublin was meant to end.
President Volodymyr Zelensky, briefed by the envoys in Ireland, was unambiguous: “It is important that Europeans, next time, next meeting, Europe will be on the negotiating team, not somewhere, not separately. They will have a voice.” A day earlier, 41 European countries had signed a French-initiated set of principles meant to underpin any long-term settlement.
What to watch
Three things will decide whether Friday was a turning point or a photograph. Whether Russian officials actually sit with the European advisers rather than repeating a two-year refusal. Whether the E5 can hold one position once inside the room, given that Poland’s eastern-flank priorities and France’s instinct for autonomy do not always align. And whether the money question is answered before the diplomatic one, because a ceasefire without financing is a pause, not a peace.
For India, this is more than spectatorship. New Delhi has argued that European and Asian security are connected, and that the Black Sea corridor, sanctions architecture and energy flows produced by this war shape Indian trade and fuel bills. India’s three-part plan for the Black Sea assumed Europe would eventually be part of any durable arrangement.
The chair is empty until someone sits in it. Europe spent two years insisting no settlement could be written without it, and on Friday it got the format it asked for. The next round in Abu Dhabi will show whether the format was the obstacle all along, or merely the excuse.
Illustration generated with AI (Z-Image Turbo, rendered locally) for The Crescent World.



