World

Modi Is in Manila for a Summit Whose Real Test Is a Trade Review

Narendra Modi landed in Manila on Monday afternoon and spent the evening at a gala dinner hosted by President Ferdinand Marcos Jr. The summits themselves come on Tuesday: the 23rd ASEAN-India Summit and the 21st East Asia Summit, with a Quad leaders’ meeting folded into the same day.

The Quad is the part that will be photographed. Modi, Donald Trump, Anthony Albanese and Sanae Takaichi will sit in the same room for the first time since September 2024, when Joe Biden hosted the group in Delaware. That two-year gap is the story most outlets will lead with, and it is a real one.

But the part that will outlast the photographs is duller. It is a trade review that has been running for years and has not finished.

The agreement nobody can name

India and ASEAN are renegotiating the ASEAN-India Trade in Goods Agreement, signed in 2009 and widely regarded in New Delhi as unbalanced. The review has been under way since 2023. Officials say India will again push for an early conclusion in Manila, which is a polite way of saying it has not concluded yet.

The Indian complaint is straightforward. The agreement cut tariffs on a long list of goods but did not open services or investment to the same degree, and it did not solve the non-tariff barriers that Indian exporters complain about most. ASEAN’s complaint is that India’s own tariff schedule has become less predictable, with duties raised on items from edible oil to electronics to protect domestic producers.

Both complaints are true. That is why the review has taken three years and why a summit communique will describe progress rather than announce a deal.

What the Quad meeting can deliver

Officials have signalled that the four countries will announce deliverables on economic security and strategic infrastructure. Those words cover a lot of ground. In practice they mean supply chains for critical minerals and semiconductors, port and cable projects in the Indian Ocean, and coast guard coordination.

The Quad’s weakness has never been its agenda. It is that the four members want different things from it. Washington wants a security instrument. New Delhi wants a technology and infrastructure partnership that does not read as an alliance. Canberra and Tokyo want both, and want the group to survive whichever government is in power in Washington.

A summit is judged by what survives the flight home. Communiques are easy. Tariff lines are not.

The Crescent World

The maritime year

2026 was designated the ASEAN-India Year of Maritime Cooperation, and Manila is where that designation gets its closing ceremony. India and ASEAN share a maritime boundary only in the loosest sense — they abut across the Bay of Bengal and the Andaman Sea — but the strategic logic is real. The Malacca Strait is India’s eastern gate, and the Andamans are the hinge.

Marcos used his opening plenary to call for stronger maritime cooperation within ASEAN and for an effective code of conduct in the South China Sea consistent with international law, including UNCLOS. That is the Philippines’ priority as chair, and it is one India can support without becoming a party to the dispute.

That distinction matters. India sells patrol vessels, radars, helicopters and drones to Southeast Asian states, and it trains their officers. It does not sign mutual defence guarantees. The defence relationship is commercial and capacity-building, which is why it has grown without the political cost of an alliance.

What India actually wants

Three things. Market access for Indian goods and services, particularly in a region that is now India’s largest trading partner bloc. Supply chain diversification away from China, which requires Japanese, Korean and Taiwanese capital to land in Indian states rather than in Vietnam. And connectivity that runs west-east rather than north-south through the Strait of Malacca.

The connectivity piece is the hardest. India’s north-eastern states border Myanmar, and the trilateral highway that was supposed to link them to Thailand has been slowed by the war in Myanmar. The Kaladan project has been slowed by the same war. Every alternative route runs through a country India cannot currently rely on.

That is the awkward subtext of a summit about maritime cooperation: India’s land bridge to Southeast Asia is closed, and its sea route is long.

The 2027 deadline

Next year is the 35th anniversary of ASEAN-India dialogue relations and the fifth anniversary of the Comprehensive Strategic Partnership, and ASEAN turns 60. Anniversaries are when bureaucracies are permitted to finish things. If the trade review is not closed by then, it will be harder to explain why it exists.

Modi has now attended thirteen ASEAN-India summits since 2014, which is a measure of how seriously India takes the relationship and how little the relationship has changed in structure. The technology pillar is the newest and the least institutionalised; it depends on deals between companies, not on communiques between governments.

What to watch

Whether the Quad produces money rather than language, because infrastructure pledges without financing are press releases. Whether the AITIGA review gets a date, because a date is the only honest signal. And whether the East Asia Summit statement on the South China Sea survives the drafting, since Russia and China are in the room for that one.

Modi will fly home with photographs and a communique. The test is whether either is worth the flight.

Illustration generated with AI (Z-Image Turbo, rendered locally) for The Crescent World.

Ganesh Kumar R

Ganesh Kumar R writes and edits The Crescent World, with a focus on India's economy, technology and its place in a multipolar world.

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button